I test drove the V6 petrol Macan S a few days ago. The dealer said the forthcoming 4cyl engine will have 237bhp.
Can't help thinking the Evoque will out-perform that version. Even with a lighter engine, the Macan will still be a good 100+kgs heavier than the Evoque. The PDK gearbox might just give it a better 0-60 time, but acceleration in-gear has to be worse.
The Macan's V6 3.0L engine is very good though! Wish they could shoehorn one into the Evoque's engine bay..
The engine and gearbox make a great howling/whining noise as you wind up through the gears
The dual-clutch gearbox is seriously smooth. The Evoque's 9spd auto is very good most of the time, but the PDK box is so smooth all of the time - I simply could't catch it out. It also works very well as an 'auto' box left in 'D' if you just want to drive in a relaxed fashion. I reckon the gearbox is probably the car's best feature.
I was disappointed with the steering. Before the Evoque, I drove a 911 for 8 years and I was hoping the Macan would have the same kind of steering feel - but it just doesn't! It's good, better than the Evoque, but only by a fairly small margin. My other car is a Fiesta ST and it does have 911/Cayman-like steering - very quick and precise. To be fair to Porsche, they have now built the best performing/handling/steering SUV to date. But when they try to tell you it feels like a 911 or Boxter - that's a stretch.
Ride quality was very good, I was expecting it to be firmer but it was near identical to the Evoque.
This was on conventional springs with PASM adaptive dampers. Apparently the air-suspension option improves the ride even more.
I was really hoping I would like the looks of this car when I got to see it in the flesh... But no.
I tried quite hard, from many angles... But no! It's not a pretty sight...
Saw one parked next to a Cayenne and, seen from a distance, you'd be hard pressed to tell which was which.
No shortage of buyers though, the dealer said they'd got 80+ outstanding orders and only 37 more deliveries this year. If I ordered today it would be 18-24 months before delivery!
I jumped back into the Evoque, ready to be disappointed having thoroughly enjoyed driving the Porsche.
Dynamically, the Macan is definitely better in every department.
But on the drive home I was pleasantly surprised to be reminded just how good the Evoque is too.
The Macan is the better drive, but it's not by a huge margin...